The Ultimate Mascara list

I liked the formula, it didn't smudge after a day of use and the applicator is really great! And also looks really great too.

I like this one, because it fans out my lashes more and I really liked the applicator. It didn't smudge after a day of use.

I like the formula, it makes my lashes look bigger and darker. The applicator is great too. It didn't smudge after a day of use.

I like the formula and the applicator. It stands out, the lashes are big and dark.

The applicator is a little big, but it's not that hard to use. I like the formula, it's thick and dark. It smudged a little bit after a day of use.

I don't love, but I don't hate the applicator. The formula is good. It's bold. It smudged a little bit after a day of use. It fanned out my lashes.

I'm surprised with the quality. I like the formula and the applicator is great. It smudged a little bit after a day of use.

I like the formula, not so sure about the applicator. It didn't smudge after a day of use. It's really nice.

Not a huge fan of the applicator, but I like the formula. It smudged a little bit by the end of the day.

I liked the formula and it didn't smudge after a day of use.

I like the formula and the applicator.

I like the applicator, but the formula it's a little bit clumpy. It smudged a little bit after a day of use. Still, it makes my lashes bigger and more dramatic, I like it.

When using throughout the day, it smudges a little bit. But still looks good.

I like the formula, but it's a little thin even with a second coat. It smudged a little bit by the end of the day.

I like the applicator and the formula. It smudged after a day of use.

It's not clumpy and didn't smudge after a day of use. The applicator is a little bit messy though.

The applicator is really thin, but surprisingly messy. It smudged a bit after a day of use. It's dark.

It's a little bit clumpy and dark. It smudged after a day of use.

I'm surprised with the quality. I like the formula and the applicator is great. It smudged a little bit after a day of use. It's dark and thick.

The applicator is great. It smudged a little bit after a day of use.

Do not like the applicator, it's too big. It's really black though, I like the formula. It didn't smudge after a day of use.

It has a big applicator.

I like the formula, but I didn't like the brush. When applicating, it got all over my eye.

The applicator is a little bit big and messy, but I do like the formula. It's dark and bold. It smudged a little bit after a day of use.

The applicator is big and a little bit messy. It smudged a little after a day of use. I like the way it spread out my lashes, it looks really natural.

This is a clumpy mess, I really don't like it. It has a weird applicator.